IAS 36 vs ASC 360: the two tests side by side
| Step | IAS 36 | ASC 360 (assets held and used) |
|---|---|---|
| Trigger | Indicators of impairment, assessed at each reporting date | Events or changes in circumstances that suggest the carrying amount may not be recoverable |
| Level of testing | Asset or cash-generating unit | Asset group: lowest level of identifiable cash flows |
| Test | One step: carrying amount vs recoverable amount | Step 1: carrying amount vs undiscounted future cash flows. Step 2 only if step 1 fails |
| Cash flows discounted? | Yes, in value in use | No, in the step 1 recoverability test |
| Measurement of the loss | Carrying amount less recoverable amount, the higher of fair value less costs of disposal and value in use | Carrying amount less fair value |
| Impairment reversal | Required if the estimates used have changed, except goodwill | Prohibited |
| Goodwill | Tested in cash-generating units against recoverable amount | Tested in reporting units against fair value (ASC 350) |
An example: impaired under IFRS, not under US GAAP
A manufacturer's production line has a carrying amount of 1,000. Falling demand triggers a test. The line is expected to generate undiscounted cash flows of 1,050 over its remaining life, worth 850 when discounted (its value in use); its fair value less costs of disposal is 800.
| IAS 36 | ASC 360 | |
|---|---|---|
| Test | Recoverable amount: higher of 850 (value in use) and 800 = 850 | Undiscounted cash flows 1,050 exceed carrying amount 1,000 |
| Result | Impairment loss of 150 | Recoverability test passed: no impairment |
| New carrying amount | 850 | 1,000 |
Because the US test uses undiscounted cash flows, impairment is recognised later under US GAAP. When it is recognised, though, it is measured at fair value, which can mean a larger loss than IFRS's value in use.
How does goodwill impairment differ?
| IAS 36 | ASC 350 | |
|---|---|---|
| Allocated to | Cash-generating units or groups of units benefiting from the combination (see goodwill impairment testing) | Reporting units: operating segments or one level below |
| Frequency | Annually and when indicators exist | Annually and when triggering events occur |
| Qualitative screen | No; recoverable amount must be estimated annually | Optional qualitative assessment before the quantitative test |
| Test | Carrying amount of the unit vs its recoverable amount | Carrying amount of the reporting unit vs its fair value; loss limited to goodwill |
| Private companies | Same as public | May elect to amortise goodwill over up to 10 years |
Since 2017, US GAAP has used a single step for goodwill, removing the old calculation of implied goodwill, so the two frameworks are closer than before. For the IFRS mechanics, see IAS 36 explained.
What about indefinite-lived intangibles?
Both test them at least annually. US GAAP tests them separately at the asset level, with an optional qualitative screen; IFRS tests them individually or within a cash-generating unit, comparing with recoverable amount.
IAS 36 vs US GAAP: why does it matter for analysis?
IFRS reporters recognise impairments earlier and may reverse them, so their earnings can move both ways. US reporters recognise them later and never reverse them. When comparing companies across frameworks, look at impairment history and the assumptions disclosed, not just the charge for the year.
Keep going
Our free Excel models work through the examples in these guides, and the comparisons show where IFRS and US GAAP part ways. Every guide names the Chartered Accountant who wrote it and the one who reviewed it.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between IAS 36 and US GAAP impairment?
IAS 36 uses a one-step test against recoverable amount and allows reversals except for goodwill; US GAAP uses a two-step test for long-lived assets, starting with undiscounted cash flows, and never reverses impairments.
Can impairment losses be reversed under US GAAP?
No, not for assets held and used and never for goodwill. IFRS allows reversal for assets other than goodwill.
Is goodwill impairment tested differently under IFRS and US GAAP?
Yes. IFRS tests cash-generating units against recoverable amount; US GAAP tests reporting units against fair value, with an optional qualitative screen.
Can private companies amortise goodwill?
Under US GAAP, private companies may elect to amortise goodwill over up to 10 years. IFRS has no such option.
Sources
The standards, updates and other documents this guide draws on.
Rules and fees change. If you are reading this long after November 10, 2026, confirm the figures with the source before you rely on them.
Related guides
More in IFRS vs US GAAP
This guide is general information. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.