IAS 16 vs US GAAP (ASC 360): property, plant and equipment

For capital-intensive companies, property, plant and equipment is the biggest asset on the balance sheet, so the differences between IAS 16 and US GAAP can move equity and depreciation materially. They matter most to groups that report under both frameworks, convert a US acquisition to IFRS, or prepare a US GAAP reporting package from IFRS books. This guide sets out every difference, follows one aircraft through five years under both, works through a revaluation, and ends with a checklist for converting IFRS balances to US GAAP.

By Mirza Fahad Baig, Chartered Accountant (ICAP). Reviewed by Hamza Fida, Chartered Accountant (ICAP). Updated . 8 minute read.

Short answer

IAS 16 vs US GAAP differs most on measurement: IFRS lets a company carry property, plant and equipment at revalued amounts under the revaluation model, while US GAAP's ASC 360 requires historical cost less depreciation and impairment. IFRS also requires component depreciation of significant parts and annual review of residual values and useful lives, where US GAAP permits but does not require componentisation. Major overhauls are capitalised under IFRS but can be expensed under US GAAP, impairments can be reversed only under IFRS, and borrowing costs and decommissioning obligations differ in detail. In this guide's aircraft example, the same US$ 60 million aircraft is carried at 47.5 million under IFRS and 45.0 million under US GAAP after five years.

At a glance

Measurement
Cost or revaluation (IFRS) vs cost only (US)
Revaluation gains
Other comprehensive income
Components
Required (IFRS) vs permitted (US)
Residual value and life
Reviewed each year under IFRS
Major inspections
Capitalised under IFRS
US standard
ASC 360
IAS 16 vs US GAAP (ASC 360): property, plant and equipmentMeasurement: Cost or revaluation (IFRS) vs cost only (US); Revaluation gains: Other comprehensive income; Components: Required (IFRS) vs permitted (US); Residual value and life: Reviewed each year under IFRS; Major inspections: Capitalised under IFRS; US standard: ASC 360.KEY FACTS AT A GLANCEIAS 16 vs US GAAP (ASC 360): property, plant andequipmentMeasurementCost or revaluation(IFRS) vs cost only (US)Revaluation gainsOther comprehensiveincomeComponentsRequired (IFRS) vspermitted (US)Residual value and lifeReviewed each year underIFRSMajor inspectionsCapitalised under IFRSUS standardASC 360Tax BakersIAS 16 vs US GAAP (ASC 360): property, plant and equipmentMeasurement: Cost or revaluation (IFRS) vs cost only (US); Revaluation gains: Other comprehensive income; Components: Required (IFRS) vs permitted (US); Residual value and life: Reviewed each year under IFRS; Major inspections: Capitalised under IFRS; US standard: ASC 360.KEY FACTS AT A GLANCEIAS 16 vs US GAAP (ASC 360):property, plant and equipmentMeasurementCost or revaluation (IFRS) vs cost only (US)Revaluation gainsOther comprehensive incomeComponentsRequired (IFRS) vs permitted (US)Residual value and lifeReviewed each year under IFRSMajor inspectionsCapitalised under IFRSUS standardASC 360Tax Bakers
Key facts at a glance, as set out in this guide.

IAS 16 vs US GAAP: what are the differences?

IAS 16 vs US GAAP at a glanceIAS 16 vs US GAAP at a glanceTOPICIFRSUS GAAPRevaluation modelAllowedNot allowedComponent depreciationRequiredOptionalAnnual residual value reviewRequiredNot requiredCapitalise major inspectionsRequiredPolicy choiceReverse impairmentAllowedNot allowed
Revaluation and componentisation are the differences that move the numbers.
AreaIAS 16US GAAP (ASC 360 and others)
Measurement after recognitionCost model or revaluation model, by class of assetCost model only
Component depreciationRequired for significant parts with different useful livesPermitted, not required
Residual value and useful lifeReviewed at least at each year endReviewed when events indicate a change
Major inspections and overhaulsCapitalised as a component and depreciated to the next inspectionPolicy choice: expense, defer, or treat as a component
Borrowing costsIAS 23: capitalised on qualifying assets, net of investment income on specific borrowingsASC 835-20: interest capitalised, investment income generally not deducted
Decommissioning obligationsIAS 37: current discount rate, remeasured each period, changes adjust the asset (see decommissioning costs)ASC 410: credit-adjusted risk-free rate, measured in layers
ImpairmentIAS 36, reversibleASC 360, two-step test, not reversible
Proceeds from items made before the asset is readyRecognised in profit or loss with their cost, not deducted from the assetNo specific guidance; practice varies by industry
Change in depreciation methodChange in accounting estimate under IAS 8, applied prospectivelyChange in estimate effected by a change in principle under ASC 250, applied prospectively and justified as preferable
Investment propertyIAS 40: fair value or costCost, like other property

IAS 16 vs US GAAP: one aircraft over five years

An airline buys an aircraft for US$ 60 million with a 20-year life and no residual value. US$ 6 million of the price relates to the condition of the engines and airframe, which will need a heavy maintenance check after 5 years. The check, at the end of year 5, costs US$ 7 million.

  • IFRS: IAS 16 requires the US$ 6 million maintenance component to be depreciated over 5 years and the remaining US$ 54 million over 20 years, 3.9 million a year. The check is capitalised as a new component.
  • US GAAP: the airline uses the direct expense method for planned major maintenance, so the whole aircraft is depreciated over 20 years, 3.0 million a year, and the check is expensed when it is done.
US$ millionIFRS expenseUS GAAP expenseIFRS profit higher (lower)
Year 13.93.0(0.9)
Year 23.93.0(0.9)
Year 33.93.0(0.9)
Year 43.93.0(0.9)
Year 53.910.06.1
Five years19.522.02.5

IFRS profit is lower in each of the first four years and much higher in year 5, when US GAAP takes the whole check to expense. At the end of year 5 the aircraft is carried at 47.5 million under IFRS, the cost less depreciation plus the new 7 million component, and at 45.0 million under US GAAP; the 2.5 million difference in equity is the same as the cumulative difference in profit. US GAAP also permits the built-in overhaul method, which gives the same answer as IFRS, and the deferral method. See aircraft components and maintenance.

How does the revaluation model work?

A company that chooses the revaluation model for a class of assets, such as land and buildings, carries them at fair value at the revaluation date, less later depreciation and impairment. Revaluations must be regular enough that the carrying amount does not differ materially from fair value. An increase goes to other comprehensive income and builds a revaluation surplus in equity, unless it reverses an earlier decrease recognised in profit; a decrease goes to profit, unless it reverses an earlier surplus.

An example: revaluing a building

A company bought an office building for 1,000,000 five years ago, with a 25-year life. Its carrying amount is 800,000 after depreciation, and its fair value is now 1,200,000.

IFRS, revaluation modelUS GAAP
Carrying amount after revaluation1,200,000800,000
Revaluation surplus in equity400,000None
Annual depreciation over the remaining 20 years60,00040,000

The revaluation raises equity by 400,000 but also raises depreciation by 20,000 a year, so reported profit is lower under IFRS. The surplus may be transferred to retained earnings as the asset is used, but it never passes through profit. Most IFRS companies, in practice, still use the cost model.

A company using the revaluation model must also disclose, for each revalued class, the carrying amount that would have been recognised under the cost model, so readers can still compare it with a US GAAP reporter.

Why does component depreciation matter?

An aircraft's engines, airframe and cabin wear out at different rates. IFRS requires each significant part to be depreciated separately over its own life. US GAAP allows it but many companies depreciate the asset as a whole, which can produce different depreciation patterns and different gains or losses when parts are replaced.

What about investment property?

IFRS has a separate standard, IAS 40, that allows investment property to be measured at fair value through profit or loss. US GAAP has no equivalent for most companies: investment property is treated like other property, at cost.

Converting IFRS property, plant and equipment to US GAAP: a checklist

  1. Reverse revaluations. Remove the revaluation surplus and the extra depreciation on revalued amounts, restoring cost less depreciation.
  2. Review components. Component depreciation is allowed under US GAAP, so most groups keep IFRS components rather than change systems.
  3. Choose a maintenance method. Direct expense, built-in overhaul or deferral; the built-in overhaul method is closest to IFRS. Accruing for future maintenance is not allowed under either framework.
  4. Reverse impairment reversals. Under ASC 360 the written-down amount becomes the new cost basis, so any IAS 36 reversal is undone.
  5. Recompute capitalised interest under ASC 835-20, without deducting investment income on specific borrowings. See IAS 23 vs ASC 835-20.
  6. Remeasure decommissioning obligations under ASC 410, using credit-adjusted risk-free rates and layers.
  7. Move investment property at fair value to cost less depreciation. See IAS 40 vs US GAAP.
  8. Recalculate deferred tax on every adjustment.

Going the other way, a company adopting IFRS can use fair value at the transition date as deemed cost under IFRS 1, rather than rebuilding historical cost. See converting from US GAAP to IFRS.

Where to go next

See IAS 36 vs US GAAP impairment, the revaluation journal entry and the key differences.

Keep going

Our free Excel models work through the examples in these guides, and the comparisons show where IFRS and US GAAP part ways. Every guide names the Chartered Accountant who wrote it and the one who reviewed it.

Questions people ask

Can property, plant and equipment be revalued under US GAAP?

No. US GAAP requires the cost model. IFRS allows the revaluation model by class of asset.

Is component depreciation required under US GAAP?

No, it is permitted. IAS 16 requires significant parts with different useful lives to be depreciated separately.

Where do revaluation gains go under IAS 16?

To other comprehensive income and a revaluation surplus in equity, unless they reverse an earlier loss recognised in profit.

Are major overhauls capitalised under US GAAP?

It depends on the method chosen. US GAAP allows the direct expense, built-in overhaul and deferral methods for planned major maintenance; IAS 16 requires the cost of a major inspection to be capitalised as a component.

Can an impairment of property, plant and equipment be reversed under US GAAP?

No. Under ASC 360 the written-down amount becomes the new cost basis. IAS 36 requires a reversal when the recoverable amount increases.

Does US GAAP have an equivalent of IAS 40 investment property?

Not for most companies. Investment property is held at cost like other property.

Sources

The standards, updates and other documents this guide draws on.

  1. IFRS Foundation: IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment
  2. IFRS Foundation: IAS 23 Borrowing Costs
  3. IFRS Foundation: IAS 36 Impairment of Assets
  4. IFRS Foundation: IAS 40 Investment Property
  5. FASB Accounting Standards Codification: Topic 360, Property, Plant, and Equipment
  6. Financial Accounting Standards Board

Rules and fees change. If you are reading this long after November 5, 2026, confirm the figures with the source before you rely on them.

More in IFRS vs US GAAP

This guide is general information. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.