Operating vs finance leases for lessees

The operating vs finance lease decision changes how a lease hits the income statement and the cash flow statement for its whole life. This guide sets out the five ASC 842 lease classification criteria, the 75% and 90% guidelines most companies use, and works through examples.

By Awais Jameel, Chartered Accountant. Reviewed by Muhammad Bilal, Chartered Accountant. Checked against official sources on . 3 minute read.

Short answer

The operating vs finance lease test under ASC 842 uses five finance lease criteria. A lessee classifies a lease as a finance lease if it meets any one of them at commencement: ownership transfers, a purchase option is reasonably certain to be exercised, the lease term is a major part of the asset's remaining economic life, the present value of the payments is substantially all of its fair value, or the asset is so specialized it has no alternative use to the lessor. Otherwise it is an operating lease. Many companies use 75% for major part and 90% for substantially all.

At a glance

Finance lease if
Any one of five criteria
Major part
Commonly 75% or more
Substantially all
Commonly 90% or more
Assessed
At commencement
Otherwise
Operating lease
Excel
Lease calculator
Operating vs finance leases for lesseesFinance lease if: Any one of five criteria; Major part: Commonly 75% or more; Substantially all: Commonly 90% or more; Assessed: At commencement; Otherwise: Operating lease; Excel: Lease calculator.KEY FACTS AT A GLANCEOperating vs finance leases for lesseesFinance lease ifAny one of five criteriaMajor partCommonly 75% or moreSubstantially allCommonly 90% or moreAssessedAt commencementOtherwiseOperating leaseExcelLease calculatorChecked against official sourcesTax BakersOperating vs finance leases for lesseesFinance lease if: Any one of five criteria; Major part: Commonly 75% or more; Substantially all: Commonly 90% or more; Assessed: At commencement; Otherwise: Operating lease; Excel: Lease calculator.KEY FACTS AT A GLANCEOperating vs finance leases forlesseesFinance lease ifAny one of five criteriaMajor partCommonly 75% or moreSubstantially allCommonly 90% or moreAssessedAt commencementOtherwiseOperating leaseExcelLease calculatorChecked against official sourcesTax Bakers
Key facts at a glance, as set out in this guide.

What are the five lease classification criteria?

Operating or finance lease under ASC 842?Operating or finance lease under ASC 842?Does ownership transferby the end of the lease?YesFinanceleaseNoIs a purchase option reasonablycertain to be exercised?YesFinanceleaseNoIs the term a major part of theremaining economic life (75%)?YesFinanceleaseNoIs the PV of payments substantiallyall of fair value (90%)?YesFinanceleaseNoIs the asset so specialized it hasno alternative use to the lessor?YesFinanceleaseNoOperating lease
Meeting any one criterion makes it a finance lease. None met means an operating lease.
  1. Transfer of ownership. The lease transfers ownership of the asset to the lessee by the end of the term.
  2. Purchase option. The lessee has an option to buy the asset that it is reasonably certain to exercise.
  3. Lease term. The lease term is for the major part of the asset's remaining economic life. This criterion does not apply if the lease starts at or near the end of the asset's economic life.
  4. Present value. The present value of the lease payments, plus any residual value guaranteed by the lessee, equals or exceeds substantially all of the asset's fair value.
  5. Specialized asset. The asset is so specialized that it is expected to have no alternative use to the lessor at the end of the term.

What do major part and substantially all mean?

ASC 842 does not set bright lines, but its implementation guidance says one reasonable approach is to treat 75% or more of the remaining economic life as a major part, and 90% or more of fair value as substantially all, and to treat a lease that starts in the last 25% of an asset's total economic life as at or near its end. Most US companies adopt these guidelines as policy.

Lease classification examples

LeaseKey factsClassification
Office space for 5 yearsBuilding life 40 years; PV of payments 12% of fair valueOperating
Delivery truck for 5 yearsEconomic life 6 years (83%)Finance: major part of life
Equipment for 3 years with a $1 purchase optionOption reasonably certainFinance
Machine for 4 yearsPV of payments $930,000; fair value $1,000,000 (93%)Finance: substantially all of fair value
Custom production line built for one customerNo alternative use to the lessorFinance: specialized

Operating vs finance lease: what difference does classification make?

Finance leaseOperating lease
Expense patternInterest plus amortization, higher earlyStraight-line
Income statement linesInterest expense and amortizationOne lease cost in operating expenses
EBITDAHigher: interest and amortization are excludedLower: the whole cost is in operating expenses
Cash flowsPrincipal in financing, interest in operatingAll in operating

For a five-year lease of $100,000 a year at 5%, year 1 expense is $108,237 as a finance lease and $100,000 as an operating lease. Compare both patterns in the lease calculator (Excel), and see the entries in ASC 842 journal entries.

Is classification ever revisited?

Only if the lease is modified and the modification is not a separate contract, or if the lease term or the assessment of a purchase option changes. Changes in estimates such as economic life or residual value alone do not trigger reclassification.

How does this compare with IFRS 16?

IFRS 16 has no lessee classification: every lease is accounted for like a finance lease. Lessors under IFRS 16, and under ASC 842 (see ASC 842 lessor accounting), use criteria similar to the five above. See ASC 842 explained and IFRS 16 lessor accounting.

Need help applying the standards?

Our Chartered Accountants help finance teams and students apply US GAAP and IFRS to real transactions.

Book a call Chat on WhatsApp

Questions people ask

What are the five criteria for a finance lease under ASC 842?

Transfer of ownership, a purchase option reasonably certain to be exercised, a lease term for the major part of economic life, payments with a present value of substantially all of fair value, or a specialized asset.

Is the 75% and 90% test still used under ASC 842?

Not as a rule, but ASC 842's implementation guidance describes 75% and 90% as one reasonable approach, and most companies use them.

What is the difference between operating and finance lease expense?

A finance lease shows front-loaded interest and amortization; an operating lease shows a straight-line lease cost.

Is lease classification reassessed?

Only on certain modifications or changes in the lease term or purchase option assessment.

Sources

Every fee, date and rule on this page was taken from these official and primary sources.

  1. FASB Accounting Standards Codification: Topic 842, Leases
  2. Financial Accounting Standards Board: Leases

Rules and fees change. If you are reading this long after October 4, 2026, confirm the figures with the source before you rely on them.

ASC 842ASC 842 leases explainedASC 842ASC 842 lessee journal entries with examplesIFRS 16Lessor accounting under IFRS 16: finance and operating leases

More in ASC 842

TopicAll 5 guides in ASC 842

This guide is general information. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.