IFRS 9 modification of financial assets and liabilities: the 10% test

Interest rate cuts, payment holidays, extended terms and debt restructurings all change a loan's cash flows. IFRS 9 decides whether the old loan is gone and a new one has started, or whether the old loan simply carries on with an adjusted balance. This guide explains the 10% test, how to calculate the modification gain or loss, and works an example.

By Muhammad Bilal, Chartered Accountant. Reviewed by Awais Jameel, Chartered Accountant. Updated . 6 minute read.

Short answer

A modification of financial assets or liabilities happens when the contractual cash flows are renegotiated. Under IFRS 9, a substantial modification is treated as derecognising the old instrument and recognising a new one. For a financial liability, it is substantial if the present value of the new cash flows, discounted at the original effective interest rate, differs by at least 10% from the carrying amount, or if qualitative factors say so. Otherwise the carrying amount is recalculated at the original rate and the difference is a modification gain or loss in profit or loss.

At a glance

Substantial
Derecognise old, recognise new
Liabilities
10% test plus qualitative factors
Discount rate
Original effective interest rate
Not substantial
Recalculate, gain or loss to profit
Fees
Adjust the carrying amount
Excel
Effective interest calculator
IFRS 9 modification of financial assets and liabilities: the 10% testSubstantial: Derecognise old, recognise new; Liabilities: 10% test plus qualitative factors; Discount rate: Original effective interest rate; Not substantial: Recalculate, gain or loss to profit; Fees: Adjust the carrying amount; Excel: Effective interest calculator.KEY FACTS AT A GLANCEIFRS 9 modification of financial assets andliabilities: the 10% testSubstantialDerecognise old,recognise newLiabilities10% test plus qualitativefactorsDiscount rateOriginal effectiveinterest rateNot substantialRecalculate, gain or lossto profitFeesAdjust the carryingamountExcelEffective interestcalculatorTax BakersIFRS 9 modification of financial assets and liabilities: the 10% testSubstantial: Derecognise old, recognise new; Liabilities: 10% test plus qualitative factors; Discount rate: Original effective interest rate; Not substantial: Recalculate, gain or loss to profit; Fees: Adjust the carrying amount; Excel: Effective interest calculator.KEY FACTS AT A GLANCEIFRS 9 modification of financialassets and liabilities: the 10%testSubstantialDerecognise old, recognise newLiabilities10% test plus qualitative factorsDiscount rateOriginal effective interest rateNot substantialRecalculate, gain or loss to profitFeesAdjust the carrying amountExcelEffective interest calculatorTax Bakers
Key facts at a glance, as set out in this guide.

What is a modification?

A change to the contractual cash flows agreed between lender and borrower: a lower or higher interest rate, a longer or shorter term, a change in currency, a payment holiday or the conversion of part of the debt. Changes that were already provided for in the contract, such as a floating rate resetting, are not modifications.

Substantial vs non-substantial modification

Substantial modificationNon-substantial modification
Test for a liabilityPresent value of new cash flows at the original rate differs by 10% or more, or qualitative factors such as a new currencyDifference below 10% and no qualitative factor
Old instrumentDerecognisedContinues
New carrying amountFair value of the new instrumentPresent value of the new cash flows at the original effective interest rate
Gain or loss in profit or lossOld carrying amount less fair value of the new instrumentOld carrying amount less the recalculated amount
Fees paidPart of the gain or loss on extinguishmentAdjust the carrying amount, spread over the remaining term
Effective interest rate afterwardsA new rateThe original rate
Borrower's entry (examples below, CU)Dr Old loan 981,012
Cr New loan 839,619
Cr Gain on extinguishment 141,393
Dr Loan liability 53,752
Cr Modification gain 53,752

Financial liabilities: the 10% test

For a borrower, the terms are substantially different if the discounted present value of the cash flows under the new terms, including any fees paid net of fees received, and discounted at the original effective interest rate, is at least 10% different from the discounted present value of the remaining cash flows of the original liability. Qualitative factors can also make a modification substantial, such as a change of currency or the addition of an equity conversion feature, even if the 10% test is not met.

A worked example: a rate cut

A company has the five-year CU 1,000,000 loan from the effective interest method guide: a 5% coupon, an arrangement fee of CU 30,000 and an effective interest rate of 5.7065%. At the end of year 2, with three years left, the bank agrees to cut the coupon to 3%. No fees are paid.

StepCU
Carrying amount at the end of year 2, before the change981,012
Present value of the new cash flows (three coupons of CU 30,000 and CU 1,000,000 at the end) at 5.7065%927,260
Difference for the 10% test5.5%
ResultBelow 10%: not substantial
Modification gain, recognised in profit or loss53,752

The entry is Dr Loan liability CU 53,752, Cr Modification gain CU 53,752. The liability continues at CU 927,260, and interest is still charged at the original rate of 5.7065%. The modification sheet of the Effective interest calculator (Excel) runs both the 10% test and the gain or loss.

A worked example: a substantial modification

Suppose instead the bank cuts the coupon to zero, with CU 1,000,000 still repayable in three years. The present value of that single payment at the original rate of 5.7065% is CU 846,632, 13.7% below the carrying amount of CU 981,012, so the modification is substantial. The old loan is derecognised and the new one is recognised at its fair value. With a market rate for the company of 6%, that is CU 1,000,000 / 1.063 = CU 839,619.

EntryCU
Dr Loan liability: old terms (derecognised)981,012
Cr Loan liability: new terms, at fair value839,619
Cr Gain on extinguishment (profit or loss)141,393

Interest on the new loan is then charged at the new effective rate of 6%, building the liability back up to CU 1,000,000 by maturity.

How does US GAAP treat a modification?

US GAAP uses the same 10% cash flow test for debt, but a modification that is not substantial produces no gain or loss: the borrower keeps the carrying amount and spreads the effect through a new effective interest rate. A borrower in financial difficulty that gets a concession follows the troubled debt restructuring rules instead. See debt modifications under ASC 470.

Modification of financial assets: gains and losses

IFRS 9 does not give a numeric test for assets; whether a modification is substantial is judged on the facts, and many companies use the 10% test by analogy alongside qualitative factors. If the modification does not lead to derecognition, the lender recalculates the gross carrying amount as the present value of the modified cash flows at the original effective interest rate and recognises a modification gain or loss in profit or loss. For a lender that has granted the rate cut above, that is a loss.

Modifications also matter for expected credit losses: the company compares credit risk on the modified asset with credit risk at original recognition to decide its stage.

How are fees treated?

For a modification that is not substantial, fees and costs adjust the carrying amount of the modified liability and are spread over its remaining term through the effective interest rate. For a substantial modification, they are part of the gain or loss on extinguishing the old liability.

Keep going

Our free Excel models work through the examples in these guides, and the comparisons show where IFRS and US GAAP part ways. Every guide names the Chartered Accountant who wrote it and the one who reviewed it.

Questions people ask

What is the 10% test under IFRS 9?

For a financial liability, a modification is substantial if the present value of the new cash flows, at the original effective interest rate and including fees, differs by at least 10% from the carrying amount.

How is a modification gain or loss calculated?

As the difference between the carrying amount before the change and the present value of the modified cash flows discounted at the original effective interest rate.

What happens if a modification is substantial?

The original instrument is derecognised and a new one is recognised at fair value, with a gain or loss in profit or loss.

Does the 10% test apply to financial assets?

IFRS 9 states it for liabilities only, but many companies apply it to assets by analogy, together with qualitative factors.

Sources

The standards, updates and other documents this guide draws on.

  1. IFRS Foundation: IFRS 9 Financial Instruments

Rules and fees change. If you are reading this long after November 10, 2026, confirm the figures with the source before you rely on them.

More in IFRS 9

This guide is general information. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.