Simplified approach vs general approach: how do they compare?
| Simplified approach | General approach | |
|---|---|---|
| Allowance when the asset is recognised | Lifetime ECL | 12-month ECL (stage 1) |
| Stages | None | Three: performing, significant increase in credit risk, credit-impaired |
| Credit risk at origination tracked | No | Yes, for every asset |
| Significant increase in credit risk test | No | Yes, at every reporting date |
| Usual measurement tool | Provision matrix of loss rates by ageing | PD x LGD x EAD, or loss rates by stage |
| Typical assets | Trade receivables, contract assets, lease receivables | Loans, bonds, deposits, intercompany loans, guarantees |
| Size of allowance on new assets | Larger: lifetime from day one | Smaller until credit risk increases |
Which assets must, may or cannot use the simplified approach?
| Asset | Simplified approach |
|---|---|
| Trade receivables and contract assets without a significant financing component | Must use it |
| Trade receivables and contract assets with a significant financing component | May use it, as an accounting policy choice |
| Lease receivables (lessor) | May use it, as a policy choice made separately for finance and operating lease receivables |
| Loans, including intercompany and staff loans | Cannot: general approach |
| Debt securities, such as bonds held at amortised cost or fair value through OCI | Cannot: general approach |
| Cash and bank deposits | Cannot: general approach, often with the low credit risk exemption |
| Loan commitments and financial guarantee contracts | Cannot: general approach |
How does the general approach work?
On initial recognition, an asset carries 12-month ECL (stage 1). At each reporting date, the lender compares the asset's current risk of default over its remaining life with the risk at origination. If credit risk has increased significantly, the asset moves to stage 2 and carries lifetime ECL; if it becomes credit-impaired, stage 3. The lender needs data on credit risk at origination for every asset, which is why the general approach is demanding. See significant increase in credit risk.
How does the simplified approach work?
The allowance is always lifetime ECL, from the day a receivable is recognised. There is no stage 1 and no SICR test. For short-term trade receivables, lifetime is only a few months, so lifetime ECL is often close to what 12-month ECL would be. Most companies measure it with a provision matrix of historical loss rates by ageing bucket, adjusted for forward-looking information. See the IFRS 9 provision matrix.
A company applying both approaches
A manufacturer has trade receivables of 1,200,000 and has lent 5,000,000 to a subsidiary, repayable in four years.
| Asset | Approach | Calculation | Allowance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trade receivables | Simplified | Provision matrix: weighted loss rate 1.5% | 18,000 |
| Loan to subsidiary, credit risk unchanged | General, stage 1 | 12-month PD 1% x LGD 45% x 5,000,000 | 22,500 |
| Same loan if the subsidiary's credit risk had increased significantly | General, stage 2 | Lifetime PD 6% x LGD 45% x 5,000,000, before discounting | 135,000 |
The intercompany loan needs a staging assessment every year; the receivables do not. In the parent's separate financial statements, the loan's allowance can be material even though it eliminates on consolidation.
Why would a company choose the simplified approach when it has a choice?
For lease receivables or receivables with a financing component, the simplified approach removes the need to track credit risk at origination and to assess SICR, at the cost of a larger allowance in early years. Most corporates choose it; banks with systems for staging often choose the general approach for lease portfolios. The choice is an accounting policy, disclosed and applied consistently.
Can a provision matrix be used under the general approach?
A provision matrix measures lifetime losses by ageing bucket, so it fits the simplified approach naturally. Under the general approach, the lender also needs to know whether each asset's credit risk has increased since origination, which ageing alone does not show, although days past due are one input to the staging assessment. Companies with intercompany loans or deposits usually measure them separately, using PDs from external ratings or the borrower's own credit assessment.
How does this compare with CECL?
US GAAP has no staging at all: every asset in scope of CECL carries lifetime expected losses from day one, which is closer to the simplified approach for everything. See IFRS 9 vs CECL, and for the arithmetic of both, how to calculate ECL.
Keep going
Our free Excel models work through the examples in these guides, and the comparisons show where IFRS and US GAAP part ways. Every guide names the Chartered Accountant who wrote it and the one who reviewed it.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between the simplified and general approach under IFRS 9?
The general approach uses three stages, with 12-month ECL until credit risk increases significantly; the simplified approach always uses lifetime ECL, with no staging.
Which assets must use the simplified approach?
Trade receivables and contract assets without a significant financing component.
Can lease receivables use the simplified approach?
Yes, as an accounting policy choice, made separately for finance and operating lease receivables.
Do intercompany loans use the simplified approach?
No. Loans, including intercompany loans, use the general approach.
Sources
The standards, updates and other documents this guide draws on.
Rules and fees change. If you are reading this long after November 10, 2026, confirm the figures with the source before you rely on them.
Related guides
More in ECL
This guide is general information. It is not tax or legal advice for your situation.